NYC Mistakenly Buffs Entire Building of Legal Graffiti

Photo: Bucky Turco

Earlier this month, the City of New York painted over a fully-sanctioned, one hundred percent legal graffiti installation covering a building on the Lower East Side after assuming that all the handiwork was done illegitimately. What took over a dozen writers several days to do, a few municipal workers undid in several hours. Ironically, it was the latter who did so without the permission of the current property owner. Some might call that vandalism.

Located on the corner of Orchard and Delancey Streets, the project was the brainchild of graffiti-trained art duo MINT & SERF. They handpicked a group of writers to blast almost every surface of the three-story space—covering it with colorful tags, fill-ins and pieces over a three-day period in late June/early July.

A photo posted by Bucky Turco (@buckyturco) on

It was done as a sendoff to Wallplay, the creative firm that rented the space and programmed scores of exhibits there. The basic concept was for these aerosol bombers, many of whom are still active in the street, to paint the building as if it were an illegal spot. When completed, the whole corner looked like a throwback to the early 1980s, a highly conspicuous graffiti landmark that may have been too convincing.

Over several months, others writers added to the mural and the site was photographed countless times. Then, in mid-September, two anti-graffiti task force vans showed up in the evening and buffed the entire building back to its highly conspicuous yellow color.

Real estate developer David Escava tells Mass Appeal that he bought 118 Orchard in 2012 and since he plans to raze it in the coming months, he gave both Wallplay and the project his blessing. But he was not contacted by anyone about the work being buffed. “I did not give the city permission to paint the building,” he explains.

According to the city, someone reported the public art to 311, setting the buff into motion. However, when the agency that assists with graffiti abatement pulled the building’s file it went off the old owner’s info. “We know that graffiti can take the form of public art, not just vandalism, and we make every effort to alert property owners before dispatching a crew to clean a building,” writes a representative for the New York City Economic Development Corporation. “In this instance, our crew didn’t recognize this as commissioned work, and we had a standing waiver on file granting the city permission to immediately remove any reported graffiti from the property.”

(Image: Bucky Turco/Wallplay)

Apparently, the previous owner had signed a waiver 10 years ago, allowing the city to automatically buff the building when a complaint is received. The NYCEDC says its workers are typically very discerning about painting over murals, RIP tributes, and other works of public art.

The city’s explanation didn’t sit well with MINT. He originally brought the proposal to Wallplay and organized the writers, a feat in and of itself. It also required permitting and lifts. “It’s very strange for the city to mistake it for illegal graffiti considering that we were out there for three days with lifts painting a three-floor building,” he says. “The local police department was put on notice about our project and the local precinct was fully aware of the fact that it was legal.”

This isn’t the first time that conceptual art by MINT, SERF and their PPP crew got buffed. In 2014, a mural they did for the L.I.S.A Project was also deemed too graffiti by local residents.

ZEXOR, a streetwise writer who participated in the Orchard Street project, also wasn’t feeling the city’s reasoning. “Who the fuck is there to deem what’s a mural and what’s not?” he asks rhetorically, “Muralism derives from graffiti. It’s the same shit.”

Related Articles


All the Graffiti On 190 Bowery Getting Buffed, Except for NEKST (RIP)


Street Heroines Crashes Through Graff Ceiling, Gives the Ladies A Voice


BC Graffiti: Richmond’s Hidden Walls, Train Yards, and Freights


ATL Artist Dax Takes Us on a Tour of “Space Mountain,” Shows Off Some Nostalgic Shit


Back When ABC No Rio Hosted An Exhibit For “So-Called Graffiti Vandal” SANE


Cartoon Mural of a Sexy Lisa Simpson Faces Accusations of Indecency in Bushwick


Latest News

lamar odom's lawyer writes espn a letter after stephen a. smith's "crack" comments Sports

Lamar Odom’s Lawyer Pens Letter to ESPN Over Stephen A. Smith’s “Crack” Comments

Stephen A. clowned Odom’s addiction on ESPN this week in a clip that’s now viral
Meek Mill's crew apparently attacks Safaree in Los Angeles. News

Safaree Gets Jumped, Calls Meek Mill “Biggest Pussy On This Planet”

Meek remains unfazed

With ‘Project E.T.,’ DJ Esco and Future Gave Listeners “Too Much Sauce”

"Yeah, all of my diamonds they shine, Haters like knock that off"
Metro Boomin drops a new song with Drake and Offset Music

Metro Boomin Drops Surprise Drake, Offset Collab, “No Complaints”—Is Album Next?

The Atlanta producer's got everybody lookin'
Zola News

Viral Dancing Gorilla Sad Reminder Of What Harambe Could Have Been

Impressive moves but... damn
tupac filmmakers sued by former vibe writer Film

‘All Eyez On Me’ Filmmakers Sued for Using Fictional Characters in Tupac Biopic

Former ‘VIBE’ writer claims the movie steals his intellectual property
Call of Duty 4 Screencap Remastered Tech/Games

‘Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Remastered’ Standalone Release Coming Soon

COD fans who skipped the $80 'Infinite Warfare' bundle are psyched
memesmahnegguh, coco mango cherry Hey, You're Cool

Hey, You’re Cool! @memesMahNegguh

Adult Swim, holler at your boy!
Banksy News

Goldie Refers to Banksy as “Rob,” People Freak Out

You do realize how many Robs there are in the world, right?

New Music From Vince Staples, dvsn, Heems and More

The Listening Room (June 23, 2017)
2017 Draft Class Sports

The Major Takeaways from the 2017 NBA Draft

Last night we watched men both younger and way more talented than us become way richer than us. Welp
Sizzla-DJ-Khaled News

The Untold Story Behind DJ Khaled and Sizzla’s “I’m So Grateful”

Khaled and Kalonji go way back
Eric B. & Rakim will reunite to celebrate 30th anniversary of Paid In Full. Music

Eric B. & Rakim Announce First Show Together in Over 20 Years

Finally let the rhythm hit 'em
essex-market-featured Art

‘Market Surplus’ Gives a Building on the L.E.S. One Last Jolt Before Demolition

Mural art show features Faust, Lamour Supreme, ELLE and more
Silicon Valley: The Soundtrack is available now. Music

Stream ‘Silicon Valley: The Soundtrack,’ Featuring Nas, Run the Jewels, Wu-Tang ...

A Mass Appeal and HBO collaboration, streaming now
Jay 305 talks about Suga Free's 'Street Gospel' album. Music

Jay 305 Preaches on Suga Free’s Classic ‘Street Gospel’